Providence Group Enterprises · RCCG Nigeria parish programme · comparison issued 1 November 2026, revised 11:20 SGT same day · author: Elena, Chief Technology · status: working specification
| Capability | EasyWorship | Ours | Acceptance test (definition of done) |
| Lyrics to slides, automatic splitting | Yes, splits per line with manual control | BUILT | Splits on blank lines and verse tags; manual override survives reload. Proven on box, harness + HTTP. |
| Live output to projector, full bleed | Yes, dedicated output window | BUILT | /present/<service> returns 200 in under 100 ms, no console chrome, no login, no cookie. Proven, 12 ms. |
| Stage display (current, next, notes, clock) | Yes, plus confidence monitor output | BUILT | Renders current, next, notes, clock; clock driven by server time so a phone cannot drift. Proven, 250 ms tick. |
| Single source of truth across outputs | Yes within one machine; multi-machine needs care | BUILT | One server-side state object; projector, stage and OBS source all move on one action. Proven: 5 actions, both surfaces at revision 3. |
| Blank / logo / clear screen | Yes, instant blank and logo | BUILT | Blank empties projector while stage keeps current, next and notes. Proven. |
| Transitions between slides | Yes, configurable per theme | PARTIAL | Cut, fade and dissolve selectable per service; no visible flicker on projector at 1080p. Cut works; fades not built. |
| Themes / templates for lyric styling | Yes, extensive theme library | NOT BUILT | Three shipped themes, parish can pick background image, font size and safe margins; verified on a 3×4 m screen photo. |
| Lower thirds and text overlays | Yes | NOT BUILT | Overlay with text and logo, toggled live, does not disturb the lyric state. |
| Countdown and service timers | Yes, pre-service countdown to start time | NOT BUILT | Counts down to a set service time, visible on projector and in the OBS feed. |
| Presenter remote over the network | Yes, mobile app and web remote | NOT BUILT | Phones on the same Wi-Fi advance slides; two controllers cannot desynchronise the state. |
| Operator preview before going live | Yes, preview and live screens | PARTIAL | Operator sees the next slide on the desk while the congregation never sees it. |
| Capability | EasyWorship | Ours | Acceptance test |
| Full Bible on screen, offline | Yes, multiple translations, licensed | BUILT | KJV full text offline; 6.2 MB JSON gzipped to 1.54 MB, serves on a weak connection. Proven. |
| Verse lookup and send to screen | Yes, fast reference entry | NOT BUILT | Type "Jn 3:16", slide appears in under two seconds, layout matches lyric theme. |
| Extra translations | Yes, several licensed | NOT BUILT | Second translation installed under licence, selectable per service. Not started because it is a licensing purchase, not code. |
| Verse lists for a sermon | Yes, saved scripture schedules | NOT BUILT | A preacher's verse list saves and steps in order during the sermon. |
| Capability | EasyWorship | Ours | Acceptance test |
| Motion backgrounds | Yes, bundled library plus imports | NOT BUILT | Looping background under lyrics, no frame drop on a 5-year-old laptop. |
| Image slides and photo galleries | Yes | BUILT | Photo gallery and camera capture already run in the member app and console. Proven 21 Oct. |
| Video playback in service | Yes, with trim and loop | NOT BUILT | Plays an MP4 from the service playlist to projector and stream at once. |
| Audio playback | Yes | NOT BUILT | Plays a track as a slide cue without leaving the presentation. |
| NDI output (network video feed into a switcher or another screen) | Yes [version-dependent] | NOT BUILT | Out of scope for R1, revisit R6. This is the one capability where EasyWorship leads us, and our R1 promise is the projector plus one livestream feed, not an NDI network output. Added 1 Nov 2026 so the gap is recorded rather than argued. |
| Import PowerPoint | Yes, PPT and PPTX import | NOT BUILT | Upload a pastor's PPTX and present it slide for slide. Judged low value: it is how sermons arrive, so it moves up if parishes ask. |
| Capability | EasyWorship | Ours | Acceptance test |
| Service schedule / playlist | Yes, drag-and-drop schedule | BUILT | Entries carry a stable id; inserting at position 0 renumbers nothing and does not move the projector. Proven. |
| Reorder during a live service | Yes | BUILT | State points at the entry, not the song, so an edit cannot jump the screen. Proven. |
| Rehearsal mode | UNVERIFIED | ON HOLD | Row held, not in acceptance. No vendor evidence that this capability exists, so it is not built or tested until evidence arrives. Added 1 Nov 2026 on review. |
| Multiple services and multi-hall output | Yes on one machine; multi-hall is licensed separately | PARTIAL | Two services on one box without cross-talk; parish isolation proven by subdomain. |
| Capability | EasyWorship | Ours | Acceptance test |
| Song library with search, tags, key | Yes | BUILT | Search returns in under a second, payload carries an excerpt and never the lyric body. Proven, 5.4 ms. |
| Bulk import from a document | Yes, from text and SongSelect | BUILT | Paste many songs, preview every doubt, commit only the reviewed rows. Proven: preview wrote nothing, commit added exactly one row. |
| Structured import template | Partial, depends on version | BUILT | CSV template downloads, loose header matching, public-domain flag understood. Proven. |
| Usable library on day one | No, empty until populated | BUILT | 28 public-domain hymns seeded, 25 visible by default. Proven. |
| CCLI number and copyright stored per song | Yes | BUILT | Author, copyright line, publisher, CCLI number persisted; copyright lines stripped from the slide body. Proven. |
| Compliance visibility (what is exposed) | Partial, a licence field exists, no exposure count | BUILT | One definition of compliant, published as a view, parish counter and audit counter side by side. Proven: parish 28/0, audit 32/2. |
| CCLI usage report for annual filing | Partial, CCLI reports exist in some versions | BUILT | Song, author, CCLI number, publisher, times used, service dates, CSV download; a song sung twice in one service counts once. Proven. |
| Migration off EasyWorship | n/a | PARTIAL | Optional endpoint only. Proved against fixtures we built, not against a real export, and no parish depends on it. |
This is the section that decides the sale. A parish does not buy a slide tool twice. It buys one system that presents on Sunday and reports on Monday.
| Capability | EasyWorship | Ours | Acceptance test |
| Tithes and offerings capture at the parish | None | BUILT | Weekly form writes to the money tables with org unit, no spreadsheet round trip. |
| Budget, allocation and spend control | None | BUILT | Spend cannot be approved without an allocation; triggers refuse it. Proven, migrations 001-003. |
| Head-church roll-up across 140 parishes | None | NOT BUILT | One page: every parish with budget, allocation, spend, reported income, variance; drill-down without leaving the page. |
| Attendance capture and trend | None | PARTIAL | Check-in already runs and survived a 500-member burst test; weekly totals still to be surfaced per parish. |
| Member app, offline | None | BUILT | Installable, Bible and lessons work with no internet. Proven. |
| Children's ministry content | None | BUILT | Games and read-aloud with four voice profiles, 188 clips, offline. Proven 18 Oct. |
| Photo capture by volunteers into the parish gallery | None | BUILT | Camera upload on capture, lands in gallery and publishing queue. Proven 21 Oct. |
| Parish shop and orders | None | BUILT | Server-side price capture, verified-paid rail, pastor verification. Proven 20 Oct. |
| Per-parish branding and subdomain | None | BUILT | Wildcard DNS and certificate live; one test parish serving in production. Proven 31 Oct. |
| Auditor view of the money trail | None | BUILT | Fund audit chain and frozen report states readable without write access. |
| # | Item | Release | Why here |
| 1 | Head-church roll-up (140 parishes, variance, drill-down) | R3, 9-12 Nov | The only item nobody else offers. Presentation parity alone does not win the account. |
| 2 | Verse lookup and send to screen | R5 | Every service uses scripture. Cheap, high frequency. |
| 3 | Attendance weekly totals per parish | R3 | Half built already; completes the reporting story. |
| 4 | Themes and lyric styling | R5 | First complaint a pastor has about any new presentation tool. |
| 5 | Presenter remote | R6 | Removes the desk from the front row; needs the state model we already have. |
| 6 | Video and audio playback in service | R6 | Expected by larger parishes, irrelevant to small ones. |
| 7 | Lower thirds, countdown timer, rehearsal mode | R6 | Polish that makes the tool feel finished. |
| 8 | Motion backgrounds | R7 | Cosmetic; cheap to buy, cheap to skip. |
| 9 | PowerPoint import | Backlog | Build only when a parish asks twice. |
| 10 | Extra Bible translations | Backlog | A licensing purchase, not an engineering task. |
| Rule | Why |
| This document is the scope of record | A capability not listed here is out of scope until it is added here first. Verbal asks become rows, not verbal builds. |
| One acceptance test per row | Work is closed by passing the test, not by the builder saying it is done. No test, no closure. |
| No dependency on the product we replace | Nothing a parish must do may require EasyWorship. Its import is an optional endpoint and stays out of acceptance criteria. |
| Parish day one is non-negotiable | A pastor must see a usable hymn library and a working projector on first login, not an empty screen and a setup wizard. |
| Texts and rights are data, not code | Public-domain hymns, CCLI numbers and copyright lines are corrected as data changes with no schema impact. |
Sources for the EasyWorship column: vendor-published capability for versions 6 and 7, plus deployment experience. Rows marked version-dependent require confirmation against the build a parish actually owns. Our column was verified on the church box (i-0fffd3156c7b68a83, eu-central-1) between 18 and 31 October 2026.